Dogar Resigns Following Lawyer Backlash: What’s Next for Legal Community?

- Pakistan - September 13, 2025
13 views 3 mins 0 Comments

The Importance of Respect in the Legal System: A Recent Controversy in Islamabad

The legal world can often feel like a high-stakes game, but it thrives best in an environment of mutual respect and professionalism. A recent incident at the Islamabad High Court (IHC) has sparked a wave of criticism and brought this principle into sharp focus.

During a hearing involving Baloch rights activist Dr. Mahrang Baloch, IHC Chief Justice Sardar Muhammad Sarfraz Dogar found himself in a heated exchange with Dr. Mahrang’s lawyer, Imaan Mazari. Their altercation escalated to the point where the judge warned her about potential contempt proceedings, ultimately claiming that her personal comments could jeopardize her client’s case.

Imaan defended her right to express her opinions, emphasizing that she was representing her client, not herself. It’s essential to remember that the courtroom is a place for arguments and legal opinions — not personal attacks. However, as Imaan pointed out, every member of the legal community should be treated with dignity, no matter the pressure at play.

Following this clash, various lawyers’ organizations quickly rallied to condemn the judge’s behavior. Statements poured in from different bar associations, including the Lahore High Court Bar Association and the Karachi Bar Association, both expressing deep concern over what they deemed an inappropriate display of authority. They highlighted that lawyers, as "officers of the court," deserve the same respect as judges.

In response to the backlash, Chief Justice Dogar sought to clarify his remarks, suggesting that his intent had been misconstrued and that he merely wished to mentor Imaan as an elder. While mentorship in the legal field is important, the manner in which it is delivered also matters greatly. Words carry significant weight, especially for individuals in positions of authority.

This situation underscores an important takeaway: respect should be the cornerstone of any profession, particularly in law, where the stakes are incredibly high. Whether in court or any other professional environment, there must be a culture that prioritizes open dialogue, constructive criticism, and a shared understanding of roles.

As issues like this arise, it’s also vital for individuals in the legal profession to engage with one another constructively. Organizations like Pro21st aim to foster better communication and mutual respect among legal professionals, helping to create a more collaborative environment for all involved.

In conclusion, let’s hope that this incident serves as a reminder of the importance of maintaining dignity and respect within the legal framework — for lawyers, judges, and clients alike. After all, the integrity of our legal system relies on it.

At Pro21st, we believe in sharing updates that matter.
Stay connected for more real conversations, fresh insights, and 21st-century perspectives.

TAGS:
Comments are closed.